Welcome to Mitel Forums. The Mitel resource - by techies, for techies...
Is the extension's Call Rerouting Alternative for what you need set correctly?
Thank you gentlemen! With a little poking around I found the Call Rerouting Alternatives field and changed it. This might be just how our system is set up, but if anyone comes across this and changing the first alternative to 2 doesn't work, try 10.